Rohingya Genocide Case: UN's Top Court Set to Deliver Landmark Verdict Against Myanmar
The International Court of Justice is set to deliver its landmark judgment on Myanmar's alleged genocide against the Rohingya, a case brought by The Gambia that could shape international accountability and justice for displaced refugees.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ), the United Nations' highest judicial body, is set to deliver a landmark judgment on November 19 in a case accusing Myanmar of committing genocide against its Rohingya Muslim minority. The decision marks a significant moment in international efforts to establish accountability for the violence that forced hundreds of thousands of Rohingya to flee their homes in 2017.
The case was brought by The Gambia in November 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention. Seven years after the proceedings began, the 15-judge panel will examine whether Myanmar bears legal responsibility for alleged genocidal acts committed by its military and other state institutions.
The judgment is expected to attract international attention, particularly from the approximately 1.2 million Rohingya refugees living in Bangladesh's Cox's Bazar settlement. Many displaced families are following the proceedings in the hope that the ruling will bring recognition and accountability for the atrocities they experienced.
According to the ICJ, the public hearing is scheduled to begin at 10 am local time in The Hague, Netherlands, and is expected to last up to 90 minutes.
How the Rohingya Genocide Case Began
The legal proceedings originated from Myanmar's military operations in Rakhine State in August 2017. The crackdown followed attacks by Rohingya insurgents on security installations, prompting a large-scale military response.
The operations resulted in widespread displacement, with at least 730,000 Rohingya fleeing across the border into Bangladesh. Survivors reported killings, sexual violence, destruction of villages and other serious human rights violations.
A United Nations fact-finding mission subsequently concluded that the military campaign included acts that could constitute genocide and recommended investigations into senior military officials.
In November 2019, The Gambia filed a case against Myanmar at the ICJ, arguing that the country had violated its obligations under the Genocide Convention.
The West African nation received backing from the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) in pursuing the proceedings.
In January 2020, the ICJ ordered Myanmar to take provisional measures to protect the Rohingya population from acts prohibited under the Genocide Convention and preserve evidence relating to the allegations.
Myanmar challenged the court's jurisdiction and the admissibility of the case. However, in July 2022, the ICJ rejected its preliminary objections, allowing the proceedings to continue.
What the International Court of Justice Will Decide
The central question before the court is whether Myanmar violated the Genocide Convention through the actions of its military and other state institutions.
Under the 1948 convention, genocide involves specific acts committed with the intention of destroying, wholly or partially, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.
Establishing this specific intent is one of the most challenging aspects of genocide cases under international law.
The Gambia has argued that the military campaign against the Rohingya was part of a broader effort to destroy the minority community. It has asked the court to establish Myanmar's state responsibility and order appropriate reparations for victims.
Myanmar has rejected the genocide allegations, maintaining that its military operations were legitimate security responses to attacks by armed groups.
The court's judgment will therefore examine the evidence, the alleged conduct of Myanmar's authorities and the country's obligations under international law.
Why the Verdict Matters Beyond Myanmar
The proceedings carry significance beyond the immediate situation in Myanmar because they could influence how international courts assess allegations of genocide and state responsibility.
The ICJ has rarely issued judgments establishing state responsibility for genocide. Its earlier proceedings involving Bosnia and Serbia demonstrated the demanding legal standards required to establish direct responsibility for the crime.
The Myanmar case could provide important legal guidance for other proceedings involving alleged violations of the Genocide Convention.
One closely watched example is South Africa's case against Israel concerning alleged genocide in Gaza, filed at the ICJ in December 2023. Legal experts are expected to examine the Myanmar judgment for insights into how the court interprets evidence, genocidal intent and state obligations.
However, the two cases involve different factual circumstances and legal records, and the judgment in one will not automatically determine the outcome of the other.
What Happens If Myanmar Is Found Responsible?
The ICJ is responsible for resolving legal disputes between states. Its decisions are final and legally binding on the parties involved, and there is no ordinary appeal process.
If the court establishes Myanmar's responsibility, it could address measures including reparations, guarantees against repeated violations and obligations to protect the Rohingya population.
The Gambia has specifically requested reparations for victims and measures to ensure the safe return of Rohingya refugees.
However, enforcing an ICJ judgment can be difficult. The court does not have its own enforcement mechanism, although the United Nations Security Council can become involved if a state fails to comply.
The ICJ must also be distinguished from the International Criminal Court (ICC). While the ICJ determines legal responsibility between states, the ICC investigates and prosecutes individuals accused of international crimes, including genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity.
Rohingya Refugees in Bangladesh Await International Justice
For Rohingya refugees living in Bangladesh, the judgment represents an important development after years of displacement and uncertainty.
Approximately 1.2 million Rohingya are living in the refugee settlements around Cox's Bazar after escaping violence in Myanmar. Many have spent years in difficult living conditions, with limited opportunities for education, employment and long-term security.
Around 550,000 Rohingya are also estimated to remain in Myanmar, where the community continues to face restrictions affecting movement, healthcare and livelihoods.
The court's decision could strengthen international pressure on Myanmar to address the allegations and protect the rights of the Rohingya population.
However, a legal judgment alone may not immediately resolve the refugee crisis or guarantee the community's safe and voluntary return.
As the ICJ prepares to deliver its verdict, the case represents a major test of international law's ability to address allegations of genocide and establish accountability for serious human rights violations.